Brees will replace Manning on my Mt.Rushmore with another SB — Whitlock | NFL | SPEAK FOR YOURSELF

  • Published: 10 September 2019
  • Jason Whitlock, Tony Gonzalez, Reggie Bush and LaVar Arrington discuss whether Drew Brees could surpass Peyton Manning. Whitlock makes the case why Brees will replace Manning with another Super Bowl title.

    #SFY #NFL #DrewBrees #PeytonManning #SuperBowl

    SUBSCRIBE to get all the latest content from Speak For Yourself:

    ►Watch the latest content from Speak For Yourself:

    ▶First Things First: Cris Carter and Nick Wright's YouTube channel:
    ►UNDISPUTED’s YouTube channel:
    ▶The Herd with Colin Cowherd’s YouTube channel:
    ▶Fair Game with Kristine Leahy’s YouTube channel:

    See more from Speak For Yourself:
    Like Speak For Yourself on Facebook:
    Follow Speak For Yourself on Twitter:
    Follow Speak For Yourself on Instagram:

    Follow Jason Whitlock on Twitter: @WhitlockJason
    Follow Marcellus Wiley on Twitter: @MarcellusWiley

    About Speak For Yourself:
    Speak for Yourself is an hour and a half sports debate show starring Jason Whitlock and Marcellus Wiley on FS1. Every day, Jason Whitlock and Marcellus Wiley will debate the day’s hottest topics in sports and offer their unfiltered takes.

    Brees will replace Manning on my Mt.Rushmore with another SB — Whitlock | NFL | SPEAK FOR YOURSELF

    Speak For Yourself
  • Sport Sport

Comments • 778

  • Speak For Yourself
    Speak For Yourself   1 months back

    Will the Saints win the Super Bowl this season?

    • Something Better88
      Something Better88  1 months back

      Speak For Yourself If saints make it to the Super Bowl we’d have to be recognized as one of the greatest NFL teams of all time. To make it there without Brees for half the season would be greater than our first Super Bowl. And the season will never be surpassed by another saints team.

    • Aidan Kearns
      Aidan Kearns  1 months back

      @Charles Buckley and mark Sanchez has 4 playoff wins lol.

    • Bray Sibley
      Bray Sibley  1 months back


  • Paul Williams
    Paul Williams  1 months back

    Brees is great but he’s got inflated stats. . He has more passing attempts then Manning or Brady . He also has more Interceptions

    • Christopher Porter
      Christopher Porter  1 months back

      Brees is 8/7 in the playoffs. That means he made the playoffs 8 times. Peyton was 14/13 in the playoffs. That means he made the playoffs 15 times in his career. Peyton has more touchdowns, more rings, more playoff appearances and wins, more 4th qtr comebacks, more MVP's. The only times peyton missed the playoffs were his rookie year and his neck injury season. This question is ludacris. They aren't even close. Drew has been to 1 superbowl. Peyton has been to 4. They talk about peyton choking in the playoffs. Drew couldn't choke when he couldn't even make the playoffs. Don't tell me had a bad defense. What was peyton carrying around in Indy? Tony G aside, this panel is a bunch of idiots. Looking at you Reggie.

      • Eric Berendsen
        Eric Berendsen  1 months back

        Was a pleasure to be able to watch both Manning and Brees sling the ball around.

        • L G
          L G  1 months back


          • Pascal Seeger
            Pascal Seeger  1 months back

            Whitlock has no Football IQ at all. Look at Peytons accomplishments, I love Drew but nah, not even close.

            • Josh
              Josh  1 months back

              Who’s the greatest quarterback of all time, Brady or Brady? Hard choice when he sits alone at the top.

              • Andrew Fung
                Andrew Fung  1 months back

                I think both of them can be on it together because Brees is the only QB to have multiple 5000 yard seasons

                • Spencer YRN
                  Spencer YRN  1 months back

                  Andrew Fung yea if you have to throw for all those yds each season it’s means your defense is garbage.

              • sonny christopher
                sonny christopher  1 months back

                Got injured ahahah

                • 5StarFilmz
                  5StarFilmz  1 months back

                  Brees is most accurate passer in NFL history....debate over

                  • nino f
                    nino f  1 months back

                    lavar sucks get him off the show...

                    • Alex Rosser
                      Alex Rosser  1 months back

                      Let’s look at those 4 seasons Brees missed the playoffs. One they had the bounty gate & no coach. Two of them they had some of the worst defenses ever to take the field. Can’t blame Brees for throwing 5000 yards & 30 TDs & going 7-9. 🤷‍♂️

                      • GodOfSouls65 FallOut39
                        GodOfSouls65 FallOut39  1 months back

                        Whitlock has to be the biggest idiots I’ve ever seen or heard 👎🏻

                        • Chad Lamoureux
                          Chad Lamoureux  1 months back

                          I'll end this conversation real fast...Tom Brady. Neither qb comes close to TB

                          • The Truth Is Real
                            The Truth Is Real  1 months back

                            Just no. 🤣😂

                            • ALFredo Cuomo
                              ALFredo Cuomo  1 months back

                              Rings are nothing but Possessions. Your Greatest Players especially the Quarterbacks like Kurt Warner, Drew Brees, Brett Favre, and so on do NOT wear their Rings.

                              • Tim Young
                                Tim Young  1 months back

                                Peyton Manning:
                                - 2 x Super Bowl Champion
                                - 4 x AFC Champion (Beat Patriots 3 times on way to SB)
                                - 5 x NFL MVP
                                - 7 x First Team All Pro
                                - 55td season (broke record)
                                - 5477yds (broke record)
                                - Led highest scoring offense n the history of the NFL

                                - Changed the position

                                Drew Brees:
                                - 1 x Super Bowl Champion
                                - 1 x NFC Champion
                                - 0 x NFL MVP
                                - 1 x All Pro (Don't even know if it was first team either)
                                - NFL career yards leader

                                To me there's no question in my mind who should be ranked higher all time, and the question is a little ludicrous. They're both great, but it's not much of a debate. I think my opinion on the matter should be obvious in regards to which one of these greats I'm referring too.

                                What do you think?

                                • paul williams
                                  paul williams  1 months back

                                  Brees is the most overrated player in history of sports

                                  • Tiger Duncan
                                    Tiger Duncan  1 months back

                                    Peyton in AFC Championship has a winning record

                                    • Cameron Santiago
                                      Cameron Santiago  1 months back

                                      HAHHAHAAH 5 MVPS VS 0

                                      • Classic Corporation
                                        Classic Corporation  1 months back

                                        Peyton. Wtf are we talking about?

                                        • • Devin •
                                          • Devin •  1 months back

                                          All the media does is disrespect these guys with these trash questions. Both QBs are hall of famers.

                                          • Jakeem
                                            Jakeem  1 months back

                                            peyton manning is better, i've never seen a qb, architect an offense as he did. it was as if he was a conductor of an orchestra.

                                            • Jacob O'Burke
                                              Jacob O'Burke  1 months back

                                              Brees isn't on Manning's level yet. Just facts

                                              • Cdiddly Son
                                                Cdiddly Son  1 months back

                                                and this is why Brady isn’t the goat cause rings are a team thing. stat wise Brees, Manning, Rodgers, Eli 2x Manning, Ben > Brady

                                                • Leonardo Yi
                                                  Leonardo Yi  1 months back

                                                  Peyton Manning is overrated as a QB in the NFL. Yes, he changed the way the quarterback position is played, but aside from the regular season, his postseason resume isn't good enough. Lost againts the saint, lost horribly to the Seahawks, won against the bears (one of the worst teams to go to the Super bowl ever), and won against the Carolina Panthers (again, one of the worst teams to go to the super bowl the last 20 years). He may not even be the better QB the broncos had that season (ouch) they won. He did play ok, not good, not great, not bad, against the Bears and the Saints. He played bad against the Seahawks, and he played horribly against Carolina. He got the MVP against the Bears, but in reality, he didn't deserved it. Drew Brees doesn't have the regular seasons MVPs Peyton has. Brees hadn't had the stability of the Colts and Broncos teams Manning had. Brees do have a Super Bowl MVP, a Super Bowl MVP he deserved, and it was against Peyton Manning's team. With one more Super Bowl in Brees pocket (and being a vital part in that run), and continue surpassing Mannings records, the career of these two men would be a lot closer than a lot of people would like it to be. For me right now, Manning is comfortably ahead of Brees, but it's not over...By the way, Eli Manning, did deserved to be the MVP of both Super Bowls the giants won with him, and he played a lot better than Peyton in the Super Bowl, coming clutch in both games. Both wins were HUGE, both against New England, and one of those were against the only Perfect 18-0 team to go to the Super Bowl in NFL History, so Eli deserved a lot of credit for those wins...

                                                  • Keelin Morris
                                                    Keelin Morris  1 months back

                                                    Just how the patriots defense won Brady his 6th ring

                                                    • Keelin Morris
                                                      Keelin Morris  1 months back

                                                      No he will never be manning

                                                      • Rob Host
                                                        Rob Host  1 months back

                                                        To be completely honest, Brees should have never even made his Super Bowl. It should’ve been Brett Favre if the defense didn’t decide to pull dirty hits all day on a 42 year old man. And since then, Brees has made no more appearances and won zero MVPs. He’s just racked up a lot of passing stats and that’s it! Not that great of an accomplished QB. Should be ranked below Dan Marino let alone Manning

                                                        • Rob Host
                                                          Rob Host  1 months back

                                                          Manning’s 5 MVPs cements him as easily the second greatest QB of all time. Along with basically every passing record although Brees has since passed him in a few. Combine that with a respectable 2 SB wins and 4 appearances and the single greatest season of all time and you get a resume that’s almost impossible to beat

                                                          • Evan Sidener
                                                            Evan Sidener  1 months back

                                                            Brees playing in a pass happy era passing yards over a career is a bad comparison

                                                            • Pek Ky
                                                              Pek Ky  1 months back

                                                              Manning > Brees

                                                              • vambo13257
                                                                vambo13257  1 months back

                                                                What about Brees calling an audible and throwing incomplete to stop the clock last year against the Rams. RUN THE BALL and burn the clock-choke job!

                                                                • Samir Pollard
                                                                  Samir Pollard  1 months back

                                                                  Peyton took 4 coaches to the Super Bowl and won a bowl with 2 different teams idgaf what y’all say if Peyton didn’t come in against the chargers the broncos not winning that game or the Super Bowl that year

                                                                  • Sean Ingram
                                                                    Sean Ingram  1 months back

                                                                    What is Lavar talking about?

                                                                    • Bryson Hartley
                                                                      Bryson Hartley  1 months back

                                                                      Bree’s has the records . The head to head in the biggest games . And the coaching relationship over 10+ years . Another super bowl puts him right under Tom Brady because it will probably be over Tom Brady.

                                                                      • Connor Bergeron
                                                                        Connor Bergeron  1 months back

                                                                        Did Drew not beat Kurt Warner and Brett Favre to get to super bowl 44? Then he beat Manning in that super bowl because he threw an interception? Yeah Brees definitely isn't clutch enough to be better than Manning 🤔🤔🤔

                                                                        • Justin Williams
                                                                          Justin Williams  1 months back

                                                                          Drew Brees and Peyton Manning would be own the NFL Mount Rushmore, along With Tom Brady and Joe Montana

                                                                          Drew Brees
                                                                          Peyton Manning
                                                                          Tom Brady
                                                                          Joe Montana

                                                                          Drew Brees is already own the Mount Rushmore. If I was to rank them this would be the order
                                                                          1. Tom Brady
                                                                          2. Peyton Manning
                                                                          3. Drew Brees
                                                                          4. Joe Montana

                                                                          If Drew Brees wins one more Superbowl he will move past Peyton Manning into second.

                                                                          • Sean Ingram
                                                                            Sean Ingram  1 months back

                                                                            Why does Mt Rushmore necessarily contain Manning, if so, could another QB be displaced is Brees ascends?

                                                                            • albundy82
                                                                              albundy82  1 months back

                                                                              Lavar Arrington's argument was stupid in this segment. Peyton threw a pick 6 in their head to head super bowl. Brees won and won super bowl mvp smh

                                                                              • BeaNs Rice
                                                                                BeaNs Rice  1 months back

                                                                                Just like M.Jordan denied alot of great B-ball players championships during his era, T.Brady denied alot of QBs superbowls during his era. Now that this 2001-2020 era is coming to an endm these late 30s - early 40s QBs better fight to the death for a ring this year, because the Patrick Mahomes, Jared Goff, Deshaun Watson, & Dak Prescotts are here to take over the next Era

                                                                                • jarnold3415
                                                                                  jarnold3415  1 months back

                                                                                  In a big game, it’s brees and it’s not even close

                                                                                  • Bradley Davis
                                                                                    Bradley Davis  1 months back

                                                                                    REGGIE WAYNE FELL DOWN ON THE PICK SIX! HE FELL DOWN! These people are children

                                                                                    • James Dawny
                                                                                      James Dawny  1 months back

                                                                                      Partnership with his coaches is a nock. Bye

                                                                                      • James Dawny
                                                                                        James Dawny  1 months back

                                                                                        Peyton over anybody lol. Tom has the bowls respect but I’d take peyton

                                                                                        • James Dawny
                                                                                          James Dawny  1 months back


                                                                                          • James Dawny
                                                                                            James Dawny  1 months back

                                                                                            If he gets one super bowl lol just cause he passed him all time we not gonna bring up. How he’ll still have more wins .mvps. Passing touchdowns probably and oh yeah he’s was just the greatest Regular season qb of all time AND played in the afc(that’s just a shot at the nfc)

                                                                                            • James Dawny
                                                                                              James Dawny  1 months back

                                                                                              Peyton was the best Qb until Tom last year